So the other day...well, more like right before Christmas, it just takes me that long to get around to posting about some stuff...William and I were driving through the parking lot at one of the shopping centres when I saw a couple get of a truck with what looked like a very new baby. I love very new babies so I was about to comment on it when I looked at the back of the truck which had a huge decal (and I mean huge, it was almost the length of the window and about a foot high) that said "Native Pride."
Let me just state that I am not against anyone being proud of their race, religion or ethnic background, but the reality is if a white person had a huge decal that said white pride they would be labelled racist. I most definitely wouldn't be caught dead with one and I would think that someone sporting "White Pride" anywhere on their person or belongings was a racist. But maybe that's just me.
So why is it okay for aborigionals to do it? Is it not a bit of reverse discrimination and while I'm on the topic, writing a post that most definitely could have people calling me racist or bigoted, here is another example:
My children are in the school system that has the largest native population in all of Canada. Each and every native child gets more funding than every other student be they white, black or brown, based soley on the colour of their skin. I am not so much bothered by this as I am by the fact that my school has a guidance counselor who only sees the native students. This is the only counselor in our school. Why does every other child not have equal access to councilling? Surely, there are other kids who must have shitty days and need to talk to someone. Oh, but I digress, here's my example (of what I am no longer sure):
Last year, our school had an aborigional day with sweetgrass, aborigional speakers and a pizza lunch. Only the aborigional kids and their parents (none of whom came) were invited. All the teachers were invited to attend, but only a handful did. One teacher explained the reason for her absence well. "You cannot expect assimilation and then practice discrimination. I wouldn't attend if my class wasn't allowed to attend."
There was a lot of frustration on the part of many parents at our school about this activity. I asked if only the Irish kids would get to wear green on St. Patrick's Day
if we were going to limit events to just kids of a particular background. At our school council meeting we asked why it happened like this, why was it that our children did not get to be a part of this event that celebrated what is an amazing culture. The answer was that they wanted to see how things went. This year all students attended a celebration on native culture - minus the pizza lunch of course.
And there's my little rant.
Oh, and my computer is a bitch and has a virus so I am not sure how much longer I will have posting abilities, it took me ages today, and apparently I can no longer comment on anyone else's site. I am so sad.
09 January, 2007
I'd be called a racist if I put something like that on my vehicle
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
13 comments:
Oh, you know? That's actually a very good point. My sister once was making a similar point about BET (Black Entertainment Television) and said she would be considered racist if she started WET (White Entertainment Television). Then I told her WET sounded like a porn channel and the conversation just got way, way off topic.
But anyway! Good post! I like posts that make people think. So thank you.
I agree with you Emma it seems to happen like that with a lot of things. I really don't get it. I know that here in the US that there are special grants and such for all racist exclusivly but none for just caucasions because "well that would be racist". Doesn't make much sense. All kids should have to work equally hard for the same things.
Also I hope that your able to get your computer working soon. I would miss your comments.
*sigh* All examples sited in your post make me twitchy. I do not get how "White Pride" equals racist but "Insert Other Race Here" pride just means...nothing? Except they use the basis that they're proud of their HERITAGE whereas being generical ol' white is different. Um, okay, you who've lived away from said heritage home for the last 200 years? WHAT are you proud of? It's not YOU it's your ancestors. The day I start claiming "English pride" because my great grandmother came from there is the day I'll be laughed away (though I happily claim my Canadian half...hey...my dad was Canadian and it helps excuse me for being American!)What was my point? Surely I had one other than filling your comments with a rant. Perhaps not. Hrm. Now farewell to the damn virus. No one needs such a thing getting in the way of POSTING for cod's sake!
I guess one difficulty I have in living here is the knowledge that any kids I have here will be deemed not quite the same in the eyes of the State as any aboriginal children born here. In Ireland you might have some people who feel children of people who settle there aren't "really" Irish but for most people being Irish is mostly a matter of culture rather than chromosomes. In the case of Travellers and so on we don't get it right by any means but there is only one court system for all citizens and no situation as in B.C. where non-aboriginal citizens are disenfranchised from municipal government as a result of a land claim settlement.
In Canada not all children born *to Canadian born parents* are born equally, let alone those born of immigrants. Those children, who may have descended several generations and whose ancestors may have had no role in "stealing" aboriginal Canadian's land, must remain in a separate state to those classified as "Indian".
Such a duality is really only extant in those countries like Australia, New Zealand, America and Canada where the British made treaties which essentially sabotaged the future nation states. Pretty much everywhere else in history land was acquired by immigrants and whoever was living there before had to accommodate, move or die.
I found a December 10 New York Times article interesting that some aboriginal communities resist scientists collecting DNA to identify historic migrations.
Geographic origin stories told by DNA can clash with long-held beliefs, threatening a world view some indigenous leaders see as vital to preserving their culture.
They argue that genetic ancestry information could also jeopardize land rights and other benefits that are based on the notion that their people have lived in a place since the beginning of time.
“What if it turns out you’re really Siberian and then, oops, your health care is gone?” said Dr. David Barrett, a co-chairman of the Alaska Area Institutional Review Board, which is sponsored by the Indian Health Service, a federal agency. “Did anyone explain that to them?”
to m - you have a point about "white pride" and being culturally specific, but "native" is as collective a term as "white", wouldn't you say?
It is funny you posted this because me and DH were just talking about a similar situation the other day.. it is sooo true!
When I first started reading your post, I was nodding along and then when you talked about the native kids and more funding, I thought "yeah, it's unfair, but they have the higher drop out rate and highest suicide rate, so probably need the help most."
But then when you went on to say that only native kids can see the counsellor, well that royally pissed me off! That's discriminatory against all the other kids and worthy of a lawsuit! So what if the nurse would only see the native kids? Then if a white kid cuts his leg during recess, he should just bleed to death? That makes absolutely no sense!
And I'm glad teachers boycotted the event. That teacher could not have said it any better. Why should she go if her students can? And your comparison to St. Patty's day being just for the Irish was so on the head, I applaud you!
I do feel that in some ways, we have so much "white guilt" that now anyone else can go on and on about their race, talk about how they'll only date/hire/etc. someone of their own race, but if anyone white would even THINK this, they're racist. And that's not right either.
Maybe I'm just naive, but I was raised to be color blind. I thought that's what Canada was all about. When I moved to the US I'd brag about how multicultural we are and how (for the most part) color-blind we are.
I'd hate to find out I'm lying!
I've learnt a lot about Canada from your post today Emma. I knew about racial tensions in the US but didn't realise Canadians had racial issues as well. I agree that everyone should be treated equally regardless of colour, culture, religion. I am speechless that the counselor is not available for all the children.
When I move to Ireland over 12 years ago I found the Irish, although lovely, to be fairly racist. They thought they were being funny but I found their joke offensive. The melting pot had finally arrived here and for the better. It is great for our children to learn about other cultures and to respect them. The immigrant workers have fast aquired a reputation as good, hard workers putting some of the Irish to shame.
When people learn to treat others with respect and equality then the world would be a more hamonious place.
Good luck getting rid of the virus, I miss your comments.
Oh, I know what you mean. My niece came home with several coloring pages over Christmas - a menorah, a Kwanza drawing, etc. I asked her if she got to color a nativity scene or something like that. She said "Oh, we can't color pictures like that because not everybody believes in Jesus." I said "Well, you're not Jewish!" Then I apologized. I just don't like double standards. It really burns me up.
(I've left this exact comment somewhere in the blogosphere before. Sorry if it was here and I'm repeating myself!)
I Just realised that you changed from terrible mother to Mum of 4 - good for you!
Nothing to say on this one except wow I thought Canada dealt with racial issues much more progressively that that, I'm disappointed.
GRRR!!! Go get 'em! That school needs some reform! Emma-style!!
I will have withdrawals without your comments.
I tried this once, and it didn't seem to take -- so sorry if this shows up twice -- anyway, it's not just the bylaws, it's the members. I don't think there's anything wrong with the concept of white pride, the problem is that the members of that club are all hateful assholes. And as long as Cheney and Rumsfeld are the best conservatism has to offer, I'll be a liberal.
I'm totally with you on this...
Post a Comment